False anti-atheist argument #1

Hitler was an Atheist! Stalin was an Atheist! Pol Pot was an Atheist!

Wrong! Wrong! and Wrong!

This turns up a lot; that atheists are nothing but immoral, child-eating, heretical, blah, blah, etc. etc.

This point of view is going to need some serious light to blast away the ignorance.

The truth is these men weren’t atheist. In the case of Stalin and Pol Pot they believed in an ideology that stated religion was an oppressive force towards the working classes and should be gotten rid off. Hitler on the other hand was a different story.

Where to start? First off, he was a bit of a mad man. And when I say mad, I mean delusional. He did express a dislike for the Judea-Christian doctrines because of the bit about caring for the weak and the poor. And also the Jew parts. But did believe.

Back to the delusional thing. The man had a Messiah complex; meaning that he thought he was on a divine mission from god. This mission of course, he believed, was to kill all Jews and restore the Roman Empire under the German Flag.

Now, stay with me on this one, I haven’t seen anyone make this argument so I may be a bit out in my analyses. Hitler did start a new religion; based on him as the new Messiah. That much is fact. He declared that all alters of the Reichskirche must have a copy of “Mein Kampf” and a sword. *Unfortunately I can’t find a reference, so it might have been under another name besides Reichskirche, but here the Wikipedia page on his beliefs*

Lets review: man thinks he’s the chosen one, sets up pagan religion which he’s the head of and person of worship. Sound familiar?

Does god king ring any bells? Yes, you’ve guessed it! Egypt and the Pharaoh Kings!

People think of these tyrants as people. Monsters yes, but  still people. So the idea that these dictators saw themselves as greater then mortals is often overlooked.stalin

Unfortunately my knowledge of Pol Pot is not as good as it should be for a post like this.  But I can state, in the case of Hitler and Stalin, that the “cult of personality” was very much used; setting up the image of these men, in the eyes of the public, as demi-gods (only a slight exaggeration), certainly greater then common members of the public.

So in conclusion, these men were nuttersnot rational, scientific, open-minded Atheists.

Advertisements

4 comments so far

  1. andrealudwig on

    I love an open-minded atheist/skeptic. For how can we discover what is really true unless we ask questions?

  2. Irish Atheist on

    Very true. If only we all lived by the Scientific Method: If an argument or belief is overturned by new evidence, the argument or belief is dropped. Simple as that.

  3. John Sutton on

    There is irrefutable evidence in Hitler’s speeches, letters and books that he regarded himself as a christian and believed in the christian god. He made many references to this over a long period and actually states that it was his Catholic influences that informed his attitude toward the Jews. The christian propaganda machine has been very successful in spreading the lie that the Nazis were atheists or pagans. This denial is an early example of the “lying for Jesus” phenomena.

  4. Irish Atheist on

    Damn history class! Told me Hitler started a pagan church.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: